A "What If" Section

LOVE this thread!

What if: Puffskein let the feeling of bitterness and anger take her over after she left her family at 8? She would probably got stuck in the negative, never learning the power of the positive. Maybe she would have been sorted into slytherin and possibly gotten into the dark arts.

Puffskein would probably not really even enjoy drinking butterbeer or firewhisky and just drank to forget her sorrows…..

WO! Mind blown! lol

What if ... Leo had never transferred to Hogwarts?

Dumbledore wouldn't have had the chance to put the charm on her that restrained Ignis - even though she's coming back - and she would have eventually gone seriously crazy, hurting many others and most probably herself in the process ... maybe even killing herself ...

Wow. Thank Godric she transferred to Hogwarts!

What if-
Voldemort had never had Rivers adopted parents killed?
Then-
River would not have hated voldemort and the Death eaters as much, meaning that she would have never insulted Crouch, and they would have not found out about being siblings. She would also proberly end up as a death eater...

Ok so I was thinking about this last night....and NOW I wish that I could go back in time and did this! grr...

Name: Liria
What if: What is Liria had chosen to kiss Crouch at a different time? Like if he had been drinking and wasn't thinking straught and Amy hadn't been there at all..Would he have kissed her back?

What would have happend: I dunno...Crouch you tell me..lol

What I think would've happened

Drinking: He would've kissed back and it probably would've lasted longer but the end result would be the same

Amy hadn't been there: Same result as it had happened. He would've pulled away. Crouch is too devoted to Amy for anything to get in between them even from a distance

That's what I was thinking..lol..it would have ended the same..but with so much more drama between Crouch and Liria lol

Yeah lol Crouch and Liria is probably the most complex character relationship in all of RP as far as I know lol

Yes..but now they have an "uncomplicated friendship".....well if it's not complicated..it's a STRANGE one lol..I mean look at their "fun" conversation..lol

I think one of the biggest stumbling blocks for Crouch in this is, he really doesn't want Liria to end up like him. Despite his ego and everything he actually has a major with himself that I won't address until much later

ooo..I kinda got that impression...that's why one of these days I'm going to ask Crouch next time he does DE duties..I'm going to ask If Liria can go..lol

LOL That will be awesome to RP! Just a suggestion when you do that, say something around the lines of "I just want to be like you" or something around those lines. I have a VERY powerful way to respond to that

I KNOW!! Last night when I was plotting some more RP's..I was all like "Hey! What about this?" so..plan on that after all this drama is over!

What if-
River was never taken away from the Crouch family?

Then-
...Well, thats the golden question, isnt it?...

Assuming all other circumstances were the same... yeah who can really say?

Well, you would not have hated our father for doing it...And as we were so close, as we grew older..Riv probs would have been able to stop you turning away from the family. you might not have turned DE. Or we both would have. hmm...interesting thing to think about...

Way I figure it, a few possibilities could've happened

Outcome 1: Our closeness would've prevented my fall to darkness and we would've led a normal life

Outcome 2: I would've become jealous of your closeness to mother and turned out the same, but instead hating you

Outcome 3: I convince us both to join Voldemort

Outcome 4: We both run from home and then it's anyones guess

Outcome 2 would have been interesting....

What if: Artemis left his family

Fueled by his frustration at the normal childhood stolen from him, Artemis would leave his family behind. After doing so, he'd become a Wand for Hire in Knockturn Alley known for his honorable practices. Hired by forces of light and dark alike he would come into confrontation with his family on numerous occasions while aiding them in others. Alas though, he never discovers his name and changes his moniker to Noise

What if Liria and Crouch had ended up together?

Hmm......I think it might have worked out....possibly....lol I have NO clue what would have happened.

I think it stands to reason it would've. I mean look at the evidence:

1. She was one of the few people actually kind to Crouch as a boy
2. Crouch is extremely protective of those closest to him so he would've defended Liria
3. Crouch would NOT have smothered her giving Liria the freedom she usually prefers

Therefore, had Crouch not joined the Dark Lord, those two could've ended up together

What if Cynder and Arty actually ended up together after the deal with Archimedes?

I dunno, just a little "huh" moment.
No clue what would have happened.

THAT is a very good question... I really don't know what would've happened.

What if Cynder ended up married?

I think if Cynder got married, she wouldn't really pursue her dreams.
In the 'Cynder's fate' thread, it shows that she ended up on Broadway.
I think if she became a bride and mother, she would want to stay with her husband and children, and not go into a serious career.

What if Crouch made it to Liria's house before meeting Voldemort?

Crouch wouldn't have been evil. Liria's parents would've given him a caring, loving household and he would be a great adopted son to them. Crouch would be taught how to work for the Ministry by Mr. Trujilio, een working to try and make him Minister of Magic. Crouch would be a constant political rival of his father. Eventually, he would develop feelings for Liria which she would reciprocate. After that, it's anyone's guess.

Aww...........Crouch always makes me so sad. I actually am starting to feel guilty about what I'm gonna do...but I'm curious as to what Crouch is going to do.